After wiping wet skin, the share of water left behind rose from 7.5 percent with an untreated towel to 21.2 percent with a standard dose of softener, and to 36.4 percent with three times that dose, in a 2018 paper by researchers at Kao Corporation, a softener maker in Japan. The plush towel you reach for after a shower may therefore leave you damper. The claim holds, with refinements: softener leaves a thin layer of water-repelling alkyl chains on cotton fibres, and the more softener is used, the more water stays on the skin. Those chains are the carbon and hydrogen tails of the softener molecule, and softener types differ in how much absorbency they cost.
The tidy story: a slippery coat
The usual explanation for why softener works is lubrication. A peer-reviewed study by Kao researchers describes it: layers of alkyl chains cover the fibres, friction between fibres falls, and cotton feels soft. The same study says this softening mechanism has not been scientifically established despite decades of use, and that some of the softness can come from preventing cross-linking by bound water between fibres.
So the slippery coat is one candidate explanation for softness. For lost absorbency, the Kao conference paper is more direct: the two long hydrophobic alkyl chains in current softening agents make the surface of treated yarn and cloth hydrophobic, which is why absorbency drops.
What the coat is made of
The Kao journal study says most home softeners are built around cationic surfactants with two long alkyl chains. Cotton fibres carry a negative charge, because cellulose contains anionic carboxyl groups, so the positively charged softener vesicles in the rinse water are drawn to them. For the towels in that work, earlier studies had found adsorption to be nearly 100 percent within 5 minutes, so most of the dose ends up on the cloth.
As the towel dries, the vesicles collapse and the fibre surfaces end up covered with layers of hydrophobic alkyl chains, which have low surface energy in air. A surface of low surface energy is one that water struggles to spread across, the same family of property behind a nonstick pan’s PTFE coating.
What was measured
Kao tested towels treated at three softener doses, given as a percentage of the fabric’s weight, and measured how much water remained on the skin after panellists wiped it:
| Towel treatment | Softener dose | Water left on skin | Compared with untreated |
|---|---|---|---|
| Untreated | 0 percent | 7.5 percent | baseline |
| Standard dose | 0.1 percent | 21.2 percent | 2.8 times (21.2 ÷ 7.5) |
| Triple dose | 0.3 percent | 36.4 percent | 4.9 times (36.4 ÷ 7.5) |
These are one softener maker’s own figures. The same paper reports that water droplets spread immediately into untreated cloth but diffused slowly into softener-treated cloth. People notice the residue of water on their skin, Kao says, and a tactile feel of coldness. Water left on skin evaporates, and evaporation draws heat away, an effect we describe in our post on a wet towel and moving air.
An independent lab agrees on the direction. Hohenstein Laboratories, a textile testing institute in Germany, reports in a trade journal paper that softener formulations can negatively influence water absorbing properties. It presents a short-time contact method suited to terry towels that can show differences between formulations.
Not every softener costs the same
Kao says the softener DODAC was commonly used after softener reached the United States market in 1955, and that its low water absorbency became a problem. Types whose chains contain double bonds, ion-complex types and imidazole types gave better absorbency, though Kao adds that it was quite difficult to match the water absorbency of an untreated cotton towel with any of them.
To see the effect on your own towels, put a few drops of water on a dry, washed towel. Kao observed that droplets spread into untreated cloth at once and slowly into softener-treated cloth, so water that sits on the surface is the sign.
Back at the shower, Kao’s team reports that panellists wiping with softener-treated towels made more complicated hand movements. They also describe a tacking sensation caused by a film of liquid between the towel and the skin.
Quick questions
Sources
Igarashi, T. et al.. A novel fabric softener system to make the softness and water wiping effect compatible (opens in a new tab), briefs.techconnect.org, .
Supports this softener maker's wiping test figures of 7.5, 21.2 and 36.4 percent, slow water spread in treated cloth, the hydrophobic chain explanation, tacking and the softener types.
Igarashi, T. et al.. Elucidation of Softening Mechanism in Rinse Cycle Fabric Softeners. Part 1: Effect of Hydrogen Bonding (opens in a new tab), pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov.
Supports the two-chain cationic surfactant composition, adsorption onto negatively charged cotton, collapse into hydrophobic low surface energy chain layers, the unestablished softening mechanism and bound water.
Gierling, E. et al.. Comparison of different methods measuring the influences of fabric softener on the water absorbing properties (opens in a new tab), teknoscienze.com.
Supports softener formulations negatively influencing water absorbing properties, the short-time contact method for terry towels and the cause of dry stiffness.
Nakamura, K.. Adsorption and Softening Mechanism of Surfactant-type Fabric Softener on Fabric Surfaces (opens in a new tab), jstage.jst.go.jp, .
Supports the 4 nm thickness of dried unilamellar softener vesicles and their collapse during drying.
